February 15, 2012
Blue ash is a long-lived tree, with some resistance to EAB.
Blue ash is a long-lived tree, with some resistance to EAB.
By Thelma Kessel

As an alternative to planting ash, it might seem odd to choose another ash. But it may be time to consider blue ash. Fraxinus quadrangulata is a rare native to southern Ontario, hardy to zone 4 or 5. The natural habitat of the blue ash is dry, limestone outcroppings. It can tolerate drought, compaction and deicing salts. Blue ash grows a little more slowly than other ashes, but can live as long as 150 years. It is well suited for urban conditions.

The Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources Species at Risk list rates blue ash as ‘Special Concern.’ Although not plentiful in the two previous centuries, blue ash was eagerly harvested for its quality wood. Current numbers seem limited by the effective girdling from a large meadow vole population and lack of interest in its ornamental worth.

Fraxinus quadrangulata is a medium sized tree with a medium texture. The narrow, rounded crown has branches near the ground. Four corky ridges make young twigs distinctively square (hence ‘quad’-rangulata). Unlike other ash, the interesting bark is scaly.

Blue ash has compound leaves with seven to 11 glossy green leaflets borne on short stalks. The leaves will thrive all season until they turn a lovely yellow in the fall. It is generally unaffected by insects.

Blue ash has perfect flowers, so each tree will produce fruit. The samara is a broad twisted wing that completely encloses the seed. Many birds and animals eat the seed. The wood of the blue ash has market value being dense like oak and as strong as white ash.

bark of a treeThe bark of the blue ash is scaly, unlike other ash species.
The emerald ash borer (EAB) will try to establish in blue ash, but reports in Canada show remarkable resilience to the pest. Of 300 blue ash trees, only one died from Windsor’s tragic infestation. Trees that did become infected recovered the next year.

For greatest genetic diversity and perhaps resilience from EAB, grow blue ash from seed. Blue ash can be found in the trade budded onto green or white ash. Susceptibility to EAB may be passed through the rootstock. Ideally seed should be obtained from FGCA (Forest Gene Conservation Association) source-certified institutions such as the Ontario Tree Seed Plant, the University of Guelph Arboretum seed orchards and various regional seed collectors. This seed from Ontario trees is more suitable to our climate than those from more southern jurisdictions. To avoid dormancy issues and low germination rates the seed is best picked in the early yellow stage. Warm stratification for 60 days followed by cold stratification for 90 days seems to be optimum for germination.

branch of a treeVery distinct ridges forming four angles give blue ash its scientific name.
Blue ash will add interest to the landscape. Its relative rareness will make each additional tree a conversation starter. And, we all know a more diverse urban landscape is the only prudent way to grow our urban forests.

For reference on the blue ash, read Trees in Canada by J.L. Farrar and Manual of Woody Landscape Plants by M.Dirr.

Urban tolerant trees

This is the second in a series of articles highlighting 29 trees selected by the Landscape Ontario Growers’ Sector working group, as recommended alternatives to ash and Norway maple. For the complete list and factsheets on each, go to landscapeontario.com/trees-for-urban-landscapes.

Funding was from the Farm Innovation Program, to the Landscape Ontario Growers’ Sector Group, which initiated the research project to develop a list of urban-tolerant trees that could be offered to the Ontario landscape industry. The project team, led by Thelma Kessel of Lacewing Horticulture, included Sean Fox, assistant manager, University of Guelph Arboretum, Jennifer Llewellyn, OMAFRA nursery crops specialist, and Dr. Glen Lumis, Professor Emeritus, University of Guelph.

The 29 trees on the list are considered suitable for Ontario urban settings, while encouraging species diversity. The research group feels the trees on this list have tolerance to urban situations, along with aesthetics and relative freedom from pests and diseases. The trees are similar to ash in size and form. Smaller specimens were included for sites where ash would be too large.